The Hindu Editorial Analysis
20th December 2023


  • Varied reactions in different regions—The recent SC verdict on Article 370 has sparked a range of responses across various regions:
  • In Jammu, there is some ambiguity surrounding the situation, and concerns regarding economic dispossession. In Kargil, there is disappointment, as the majority Shia community wishes for a different outcome. In Ladakh, there is a cautious welcome, but a desire for elected administration. In the Valley, there is an ominous sentiment, and many are uncertain about what lies ahead.
  • Severe impact on the Valley, reinforcing a belief of resentment and silencing of Kashmiris’ voices.
  • Security Concerns and Court’s View: Draconian circumstances during President’s August 2019 orders not adequately acknowledged, potential danger in unwarranted arrests and limiting policy debates, Neglect of the importance of peacemaking in resolving internal conflict.
  • Human Rights and Violence: Justice Kaul’s ‘epilogue’ acknowledges human rights abuses but overlooks violations since August 2019. Rise in violence post-2019 contrasts with the decline during the 2002-13 peace process. Lack of emphasis on the lesson that peacemaking offers a better solution to internal conflict.
  • Moving Forward : Suggestion for the Union administration to initiate a new peace process. Recommendations include restoring statehood, holding elections, and returning freedom of expression. Acknowledgment of potential anger and the need for compassionate responses, Reference to the A.B. Vajpayee and Manmohan Singh blueprint for disarmament, demilitarization, soft borders, and autonomy.
  • Conclusion: The Supreme Court’s Jammu and Kashmir judgment holds vast implications, urging a critical examination of its constitutional, regional, and security dimensions.The neglected aspects underscore the need for comprehensive reevaluation and future considerations.
  • A new 46-page statute aims to consolidate regulations for wireless networks and internet service providers. The law maintains current regulatory structures, simplifies bureaucratic procedures and introduces digitization of licensing processes. It also includes new mechanisms to address non-compliance with license terms.
  • Local Authority Access: Telecom operators granted access to district- and State-level authorities for permissions and dispute resolution.
  • The satellite internet industry in India has been exempted from bidding for spectrum, which has been welcomed by industry bodies for promoting ease of doing business and streamlining regulations. This move aligns with global practices and has the potential to provide regulatory stability for the next phase of telecom expansion in the country.
  • The definition of telecom raises privacy and surveillance concerns, and there is a need for transparent handling of public responses during consultation and rule-making processes. The evolving digital landscape since the 19th century requires subordinate legislation for the Act's provisions.
  • NOTE: Subordinate legislation is a process by which the executive is given powers by primary legislation to make laws in order to implement and administer the requirements of that primary legislation.
  • High Fat, Sugar, and Salt (HFSS) Consumption Impact: Major risk factor for health issues including obesity, diabetes, and high blood pressure.
  • World Bank report (2019): 70% of overweight/obese people in Low- and Middle-Income Countries.
  • NCDs burden in India increased from 38% (1990) to 65% (2019).
  • India’s Dietary Shift: Ultra-processed food sector CAGR(Compound annual growth rate): 13.4% (2011-2021).
  • India is the largest producer and consumer of sugar (2022).
  • Sales of snacks and soft drinks exceeded $30 billion, indicating concerning dietary trends.
  • Health and Economic Implications: Non-communicable Diseases (NCDs) burden in India. Annual deaths in India: 1.2 million attributed to dietary risks.
  • Global Fiscal Measures: Global trend follows using fiscal measures to combat obesity.
  • Sugar-sweetened beverages (SSBs) taxed in 60+ countries.
  • HFSS food tax in 16 countries including Denmark, France, Mexico, UK, and US.
  • Societal costs, increased health-care expenditures, Limited consumer understanding influenced by aggressive marketing.
  • Taxation Objectives:Incentivize industry reformulation for healthier products, Encourage people to prioritize healthier alternatives, Non-regressive and fiscally neutral design to make healthier choices more affordable.
  • GST and Nutritional Content: Current GST rates not aligned with nutritional impact of ultra-processed foods, Inconsistencies in taxing aerated beverages, juices, and salty snacks irrespective of nutritional content.
  • HFSS taxation should be a public health imperative, promoting healthier food choices.
  • Conclusion: HFSS taxation is imperative to address health risks, combat obesity, and alleviate the economic burden. Designing non-regressive and nutrition-focused taxes is vital for fostering a healthier and sustainable food system.
  • Over 100 countries commit to tripling global renewable energy capacity by 2030 at COP28.
  • India's Struggle to Achieve 20% Ethanol Blending Target by 2025 - This is due to low sugar stocks and a shortfall in sugarcane production.
  • Government plans a shift to grains-based ethanol, focusing on maize; NAFED and NCCF authorized for procurement.
  • The production of ethanol from corn has raised concerns about the potential conflict between fuel and food. This has caused food prices to become tied to crude oil prices. Due to differential pricing in India, sugar stocks have been reduced. In December 2023, the government issued a corrective ban on using cane juice for ethanol.
  • Shifting to grains-based ethanol to meet targets may pose a risk of uncontrollable food inflation.
  • Alternatives include reconsidering ethanol blending targets, investing in public infrastructure, urban design, and promoting renewable energy like solar power.
  • Conclusion: While India's pursuit of renewable energy and ethanol blending targets are admirable, it is essential to consider the potential impacts on food supply and inflation. Striking a balance between these factors is critical for a sustainable and resilient future.